| #336 | 5-Alarm Saucepan | 1 |
| #4300 | Baron von Ratsworth's monocle | 1 |
| #2772 | Boss Bat britches | 1 |
| #856 | Brimstone Chicken Sandwich | 2 |
| #2462 | Colander of Em-er'il | 1 |
| #3593 | Crown of the Goblin King | 2 |
| #1416 | Dolphin King's crown | 2 |
| #843 | Double Bacon Beelzeburger | 2 |
| #1783 | El Sombrero De Lopez | 1 |
| #1599 | Glass Balls of the Goblin King | 1 |
| #732 | Jumbo Dr. Lucifer | 5 |
| #1208 | Knob Goblin firecracker | 1 |
| #1016 | Knoll mushroom | 1 |
| #782 | Lord of the Flies-sized fries | 3 |
| #291 | Pasta Spoon of Peril | 1 |
| #200 | Unionize The Elves sign | 1 |
| #769 | aspirin | 1 |
| #7432 | badass belt | 1 |
| #2043 | ball | 1 |
| #901 | baseball | 1 |
| #1062 | bell-shaped Crimbo cookie | 1 |
| #2562 | black paisley oyster egg | 1 |
| #2108 | black plastic oyster egg | 1 |
| #1475 | black striped oyster egg | 3 |
| #810 | blue paisley oyster egg | 5 |
| #761 | blue striped oyster egg | 6 |
| 🥈 | blue traffic cone | 1 |
| #3683 | bottle of goofballs | 3 |
| #795 | bubbly potion | 3 |
| #547 | can of fake snow | 1 |
| #1823 | cheap plastic bottle opener | 1 |
| #983 | chrome ore | 1 |
| #869 | cloudy potion | 2 |
| #1141 | cog | 1 |
| #811 | dark potion | 3 |
| #1526 | disco ball | 3 |
| #1255 | disco mask | 5 |
| #1025 | disease | 1 |
| #1129 | dry noodles | 1 |
| #1504 | drywall axe | 3 |
| #1476 | duck-on-a-string | 1 |
| #4231 | easter egg balloon | 2 |
| #947 | effervescent potion | 1 |
| #766 | eye of newt | 4 |
| #968 | fancy chocolate | 3 |
| #697 | felt | 13 |
| #1921 | giant discarded plastic fork | 2 |
| #550 | googly eye | 24 |
| 🥈 | green traffic cone | 1 |
| #4469 | grue egg | 2 |
| #1252 | helmet turtle | 9 |
| #2061 | kite | 1 |
| #1485 | lavender paisley oyster egg | 2 |
| #1764 | lavender striped oyster egg | 1 |
| #398 | length of string | 30 |
| #1299 | mariachi pants | 1 |
| #1086 | marionette | 1 |
| #2253 | mauve plastic oyster egg | 1 |
| #1845 | mauve polka-dot oyster egg | 1 |
| #785 | milky potion | 3 |
| #911 | murky potion | 1 |
| #875 | off-white paisley oyster egg | 2 |
| #1822 | off-white plastic oyster egg | 2 |
| #900 | off-white polka-dot oyster egg | 3 |
| #1580 | off-white striped oyster egg | 1 |
| #865 | oriole-feather headdress | 1 |
| #1313 | pail | 3 |
| #1172 | pants of the Slug Lord | 2 |
| #1294 | pasta spoon | 3 |
| #810 | potted cactus | 1 |
| #2033 | puce paisley oyster egg | 1 |
| #2102 | puce plastic oyster egg | 1 |
| #2250 | puce polka-dot oyster egg | 1 |
| #1303 | rag doll | 1 |
| #1076 | ravioli hat | 6 |
| #1513 | red paisley oyster egg | 2 |
| #837 | red polka-dot oyster egg | 4 |
| #1646 | red striped oyster egg | 1 |
| #1298 | rib of the Bonerdagon | 1 |
| #981 | salamander spleen | 1 |
| #1114 | saucepan | 11 |
| #773 | seal tooth | 6 |
| #1301 | seal-clubbing club | 4 |
| #2572 | shiny ring | 2 |
| #734 | smoky potion | 4 |
| #1349 | sock monkey | 1 |
| #980 | spring | 2 |
| #704 | sprocket | 13 |
| #901 | squashed frog | 3 |
| #2242 | stainless steel shillelagh | 1 |
| #1341 | stolen accordion | 5 |
| #3199 | stuffed doppelshifter | 1 |
| #506 | stuffing | 18 |
| #842 | swirly potion | 2 |
| #3983 | tiny plastic Cheshire bat | 4 |
| #4308 | tiny plastic Crimbo elf | 1 |
| #4229 | tiny plastic Crimbo reindeer | 1 |
| #2898 | tiny plastic Crimbo wreath | 1 |
| #1548 | tiny plastic Crimboween pentagram | 1 |
| #1530 | tiny plastic Scream Queen | 1 |
| #2947 | tiny plastic Uncle Crimbo | 1 |
| #1731 | tiny plastic ancient yuletide troll | 1 |
| #8194 | tiny plastic angry goat | 1 |
| #4855 | tiny plastic baby gravy fairy | 3 |
| #8107 | tiny plastic barrrnacle | 1 |
| #4878 | tiny plastic coffee pixie | 3 |
| #4490 | tiny plastic disco bandit | 1 |
| #4874 | tiny plastic fuzzy dice | 3 |
| #6225 | tiny plastic ghost pickle on a stick | 2 |
| #1736 | tiny plastic gift-wrapping vampire | 1 |
| #6082 | tiny plastic grue | 2 |
| #8113 | tiny plastic howling balloon monkey | 1 |
| #6062 | tiny plastic killer bee | 2 |
| #3964 | tiny plastic leprechaun | 4 |
| #8086 | tiny plastic levitating potato | 1 |
| #4340 | tiny plastic pastamancer | 1 |
| #6119 | tiny plastic sabre-toothed lime | 2 |
| #4458 | tiny plastic sauceror | 1 |
| #4445 | tiny plastic seal clubber | 1 |
| #4003 | tiny plastic spooky pirate skeleton | 4 |
| #6123 | tiny plastic stab bat | 2 |
| #6156 | tiny plastic star starfish | 2 |
| #4038 | tiny plastic sweet nutcracker | 1 |
| #2653 | tiny plastic turtle tamer | 2 |
| #2068 | top | 1 |
| #1190 | toy soldier | 1 |
| #1384 | toy train | 1 |
| #201 | toy wheel | 43 |
| #524 | tree-shaped Crimbo cookie | 2 |
| #1051 | turtle totem | 14 |
| #394 | wooden block | 8 |
| #1796 | yellow paisley oyster egg | 1 |
| #682 | yellow plastic oyster egg | 9 |
| #879 | yellow polka-dot oyster egg | 2 |
| #1061 | yellow striped oyster egg | 2 |