| #639 | "DRINK ME" potion | 1 |
| #441 | 4-dimensional guitar | 1 |
| #815 | Blizzards I Have Died In | 1 |
| #423 | Boris's key lime pie | 1 |
| #388 | Cold Hots candy | 14 |
| #754 | Crimbo pie | 1 |
| #167 | Crimbo wreath | 4 |
| #537 | Daffy Taffy | 55 |
| #81 | El Vibrato punchcard (104 holes) | 1 |
| #160 | El Vibrato punchcard (115 holes) | 1 |
| #216 | El Vibrato punchcard (165 holes) | 1 |
| #231 | El Vibrato punchcard (176 holes) | 1 |
| #197 | El Vibrato punchcard (213 holes) | 1 |
| #298 | El Vibrato punchcard (88 holes) | 1 |
| #283 | El Vibrato punchcard (97 holes) | 1 |
| #83 | Gummi-DNA | 21 |
| #613 | Hell ramen | 1 |
| #396 | Jarlsberg's key lime pie | 1 |
| #1209 | Mr. Mediocrebar | 33 |
| #472 | Necrotelicomnicon | 1 |
| #1691 | Rock Pops | 16 |
| #599 | Senior Mints | 7 |
| #399 | Sneaky Pete's key lime pie | 1 |
| #343 | Spooky Surprise Egg | 35 |
| #536 | Steal This Candy | 2 |
| #964 | Wint-O-Fresh mint | 9 |
| #1481 | Yummy Tummy bean | 88 |
| #916 | Zu Mannkäse Dienen | 1 |
| #365 | a butt tuba | 1 |
| #266 | abandoned candy | 2 |
| #622 | alphabet gum | 1 |
| #375 | antique bottle of cough syrup | 1 |
| #105 | badass pie | 1 |
| #1215 | baggie of powdered sugar | 1 |
| #338 | banana cream pie | 1 |
| #249 | battered Crimbo Crate | 50 |
| #456 | bottle of Vangoghbitussin | 1 |
| #129 | brick of sand | 16 |
| #580 | brown sugar cane | 2 |
| #384 | candied kobold | 8 |
| #858 | candy brain | 1 |
| #274 | cherry pie | 1 |
| #606 | chocolate filthy lucre | 2 |
| #951 | crazy little Turkish delight | 1 |
| #111 | dead lights pie | 1 |
| #379 | digital key lime pie | 1 |
| #160 | dusty Crimbo crate | 50 |
| #163 | extra-potent gremlin mutagen | 1 |
| #275 | flower petal pie | 1 |
| #151 | gingerbread house | 4 |
| #171 | ginormous pumpkin | 1 |
| #260 | half-baked potion | 1 |
| #575 | honey-dipped locust | 1 |
| #82 | igloo pie | 1 |
| #1052 | jabañero-flavored chewing gum | 2 |
| #362 | lemon meringue pie | 1 |
| #624 | lihc eye pie | 1 |
| #1047 | lime-and-chile-flavored chewing gum | 2 |
| #137 | liver and let pie | 1 |
| #1194 | marzipan skull | 2 |
| #646 | mother's little helper | 1 |
| #225 | peach pie | 1 |
| #877 | pickle-flavored chewing gum | 4 |
| #207 | piece of after eight | 1 |
| #1096 | pile of candy | 1 |
| #505 | pink pony | 2 |
| #72 | piping organ pie | 1 |
| #589 | pixellated candy heart | 20 |
| #178 | plastic Crimbo reindeer | 4 |
| #131 | pumpkin pie | 1 |
| #335 | purple pixel pie | 1 |
| #771 | shingle | 1 |
| #70 | shoo-fish pie | 1 |
| #338 | star key lime pie | 1 |
| #320 | strawberry pie | 1 |
| #161 | string of Crimbo lights | 4 |
| #329 | sturdy Crimbo crate | 50 |
| #958 | tamarind-flavored chewing gum | 3 |
| #1620 | thin black candle | 1 |
| #82 | throbbing organ pie | 1 |
| #999 | tiny bottle of absinthe | 1 |