| #2661 | Disco 'Fro Pick | 1 |
| #2384 | Elder Turtle Shell | 1 |
| 🥈 | Junior LAAAAME merit badge | 1 |
| #107 | Kentucky-style derby | 1 |
| #2541 | Scalp of Gorgolok | 1 |
| #227 | anniversary chutney sculpture | 1 |
| #288 | arrow'd heart balloon | 2 |
| #567 | bag of Cheat-Os | 9 |
| #747 | bag of airline peanuts | 37 |
| #1912 | bat-shaped Crimboween cookie | 1 |
| #681 | black candy heart | 4 |
| 🥈 | blue ribbon | 1 |
| #5026 | bottle of goofballs | 1 |
| #1073 | bottle of single-barrel whiskey | 1 |
| #2027 | box of sunshine | 66 |
| #230 | boxed champagne | 6 |
| #1220 | brick | 20 |
| #684 | cardboard wakizashi | 1 |
| #997 | cheap toaster | 2 |
| #522 | clown hammer | 53 |
| #395 | double daisy | 1 |
| #4232 | easter egg balloon | 2 |
| #618 | encoder ring | 19 |
| #920 | explosion-flavored chewing gum | 22 |
| #411 | eye of newt | 20 |
| #556 | fake fake vomit | 57 |
| #742 | fake hand | 31 |
| #462 | fortune cookie | 1 |
| #3220 | fuzzy dice | 2 |
| #4476 | grue egg | 2 |
| #615 | heart-shaped balloon | 7 |
| #43 | jar of anniversary jam | 1 |
| #724 | jazz soap | 37 |
| #769 | joybuzzer | 34 |
| #671 | lucky rabbit's foot | 10 |
| #1030 | magical ice cube with a fly in it | 18 |
| #487 | miniature stuffed Goth Giant | 1 |
| #1125 | pet rock "Groucho" disguise | 10 |
| #921 | pet rock "Snooty" disguise | 25 |
| #1303 | rag doll | 1 |
| #993 | rubber emo roe | 24 |
| #485 | salamander spleen | 14 |
| #237 | squashed frog | 71 |
| #5353 | stuffed astral badger | 6 |
| #1100 | whoopie cushion | 18 |
| #804 | wind-up chattering teeth | 35 |
| #528 | x-ray specs | 36 |
| #620 | yellow snowcone | 53 |