| #803 | Angry Farmer candy | 62 |
| #273 | Angry Farmer's Wife Candy | 3 |
| #232 | Arrrmetia trading card | 1 |
| #932 | Better Than Cuddling Cake | 1 |
| #193 | Bit O' Ectoplasm | 12 |
| #864 | Cold Hots candy | 3 |
| #109 | Crimbo P. R. E. S. S. I. E. | 1 |
| #477 | Daffy Taffy | 67 |
| #344 | Gummi-Gnauga | 7 |
| #777 | Mick's IcyVapoHotness Inhaler | 3 |
| #1100 | Mr. Mediocrebar | 39 |
| #233 | Princess Rutabaga trading card | 1 |
| #1197 | Rock Pops | 35 |
| #801 | Senior Mints | 4 |
| #454 | Steal This Candy | 3 |
| #61 | Time Juice | 8 |
| #47 | V for Vivala mask | 1 |
| #724 | Valentine | 24 |
| #618 | Wint-O-Fresh mint | 16 |
| #228 | Woldo trading card | 1 |
| #139 | Yeti Protest Sign | 1 |
| #958 | Yummy Tummy bean | 173 |
| #184 | alphabet gum | 10 |
| 🥈 | anniversary chutney sculpture | 2 |
| #355 | beertini | 5 |
| #1464 | black plastic oyster egg | 2 |
| #269 | black velvet box | 1 |
| #1032 | blue plastic oyster egg | 4 |
| #157 | blue polka-dot oyster egg | 20 |
| #5026 | bottle of goofballs | 1 |
| #771 | bouquet of circular saw blades | 1 |
| #562 | broken skull | 22 |
| #2396 | can-shaped gelatinous cranberry sauce | 2 |
| #2359 | candied yams | 2 |
| #214 | candy brain | 19 |
| #526 | carob chunk cookies | 2 |
| #328 | carob chunk noodles | 5 |
| #939 | chocolate-covered diamond-studded roses | 1 |
| #384 | chorizo brownies | 4 |
| #507 | colored-light "necklace" | 1 |
| #883 | commemorative war stein | 1 |
| #2467 | diamond necklace | 2 |
| #539 | dwarf bread | 7 |
| #74 | exactly-three-shaped box | 1 |
| #761 | fake blood | 1 |
| #572 | fancy seashell necklace | 1 |
| #692 | [2426]fire flower | 1 |
| #281 | freezerburned ice cube | 1 |
| #594 | green balloon | 2 |
| #797 | green candy heart | 5 |
| #3382 | heart necklace | 1 |
| #2516 | herbal stuffing | 1 |
| 🥇 | jar of anniversary jam | 2 |
| #178 | less-than-three-shaped box | 1 |
| #473 | maple syrup | 8 |
| #971 | mauve striped oyster egg | 4 |
| #120 | miniature coffin | 1 |
| #876 | off-white paisley oyster egg | 2 |
| #1123 | off-white plastic oyster egg | 4 |
| #1734 | off-white polka-dot oyster egg | 1 |
| #1583 | off-white striped oyster egg | 1 |
| #477 | papaya slung | 2 |
| #1153 | pink candy heart | 1 |
| #639 | pixellated candy heart | 18 |
| #238 | poltergeist-in-the-jar-o | 3 |
| #1675 | roll of toilet paper | 10 |
| #2723 | rubber WWBD? bracelet | 2 |
| #2797 | rubber WWJD? bracelet | 2 |
| #3658 | rubber WWSPD? bracelet | 1 |
| #2735 | rubber WWtNSD? bracelet | 2 |
| #234 | salty slug | 7 |
| #3320 | spade necklace | 1 |
| 🥇 | spandex anniversary shorts | 2 |
| #4206 | stuffed Cheshire bitten | 9 |
| #6274 | stuffed MagiMechTech MicroMechaMech | 4 |
| #6271 | stuffed angry cow | 4 |
| #7830 | stuffed astral badger | 2 |
| #8948 | stuffed baby gravy fairy | 1 |
| #907 | stuffed can of asparagus | 2 |
| #4485 | stuffed cocoabo | 8 |
| #718 | stuffed dodecapede | 3 |
| #6372 | stuffed flaming gravy fairy | 4 |
| #7025 | stuffed frozen gravy fairy | 3 |
| #6331 | stuffed hand turkey | 4 |
| #7826 | stuffed mind flayer | 2 |
| #714 | stuffed ninja snowman | 5 |
| #3807 | stuffed scary death orb | 11 |
| #3417 | stuffed shoulder parrot | 3 |
| #6372 | stuffed sleazy gravy fairy | 4 |
| #4742 | stuffed snowy owl | 7 |
| #6332 | stuffed spooky gravy fairy | 4 |
| #1974 | stuffed spooky mushroom | 3 |
| #5739 | stuffed stinky gravy fairy | 5 |
| #5781 | stuffed undead elbow macaroni | 5 |
| #2643 | stuffing | 1 |
| #501 | teeny-tiny ninja stars | 1 |
| #1721 | toast | 168 |
| #545 | tofu casserole | 1 |
| #2299 | tofurkey gravy | 2 |
| #2296 | tofurkey leg | 2 |
| #250 | tomato daiquiri | 6 |
| #599 | tropical paperweight | 1 |
| #1132 | tropical wrapping paper | 1 |
| #1001 | valuable trinket | 53 |
| #630 | white balloon | 2 |
| #1014 | white candy heart | 2 |
| #871 | white chocolate and tomato pizza | 1 |
| #1183 | yellow candy heart | 2 |
| #510 | yellow plastic oyster egg | 12 |
| #881 | yellow polka-dot oyster egg | 2 |