| #135 | Boulevardier cocktail | 1 |
| #153 | Dreadsylvanian Almanac page | 35 |
| #29 | Great Wolf's left paw | 1 |
| #131 | Hollandaise helmet | 80 |
| #111 | Hotwire™ brand candy rope | 1 |
| #1441 | Thwaitgold maggot statuette | 2 |
| #316 | Thwaitgold metabug statuette | 1 |
| #465 | Thwaitgold mosquito statuette | 3 |
| #26 | Unkillable Skeleton's shinguards | 1 |
| #227 | anniversary chutney sculpture | 1 |
| 🥇 | bucket of anniversary lard | 1 |
| #152 | burst hellseal brain | 56 |
| #455 | disco ball | 76 |
| #419 | disco mask | 79 |
| #344 | donated booze | 19 |
| #265 | donated candy | 29 |
| #404 | donated food | 9 |
| #49 | drive-thru burger | 7 |
| #130 | eternal car battery | 1 |
| #99 | filthy child leash | 1 |
| #1460 | friendly cheez blob | 1 |
| #394 | goat | 1 |
| #984 | guy made of bee pollen | 1 |
| #529 | helmet turtle | 73 |
| #43 | jar of anniversary jam | 1 |
| #1123 | lead necklace | 2 |
| #180 | mariachi hat | 45 |
| #613 | old sweatpants | 105 |
| #385 | pasta spoon | 67 |
| #130 | pregnant oily golden mushroom | 1 |
| #387 | ravioli hat | 68 |
| #545 | saucepan | 72 |
| #424 | seal-clubbing club | 79 |
| #269 | seal-skull helmet | 54 |
| #180 | shredded hellseal hide | 38 |
| #106 | spandex anniversary shorts | 1 |
| #526 | stolen accordion | 66 |
| #8981 | stuffed astral badger | 1 |
| #6374 | stuffed baby gravy fairy | 4 |
| #6852 | stuffed cocoabo | 3 |
| #8927 | stuffed flaming gravy fairy | 1 |
| #7823 | stuffed frozen gravy fairy | 2 |
| #7879 | stuffed hand turkey | 2 |
| #1716 | stuffed ninja snowman | 1 |
| #7889 | stuffed scary death orb | 2 |
| #4806 | stuffed shoulder parrot | 1 |
| #7684 | stuffed snowy owl | 2 |
| #7801 | stuffed spooky gravy fairy | 2 |
| #7777 | stuffed stinky gravy fairy | 2 |
| #8895 | stuffed undead elbow macaroni | 1 |
| #3991 | tiny plastic 7-foot dwarf | 1 |
| #65 | tiny plastic Abuela Crimbo | 1 |
| #3116 | tiny plastic Baron von Ratsworth | 1 |
| #1156 | tiny plastic Battlesuit Bugbear Type | 1 |
| #3180 | tiny plastic Bonerdagon | 1 |
| #3081 | tiny plastic Boss Bat | 1 |
| #61 | tiny plastic Café Elf | 1 |
| #59 | tiny plastic Dolph Bossin | 1 |
| #336 | tiny plastic Gary Claybender | 3 |
| #794 | tiny plastic Jared the Duskwalker | 1 |
| #1149 | tiny plastic Knob Goblin King | 4 |
| #3960 | tiny plastic Knob Goblin bean counter | 1 |
| #3873 | tiny plastic Knob Goblin harem girl | 1 |
| #3915 | tiny plastic Knob Goblin mad scientist | 1 |
| #47 | tiny plastic Mer-kin baker | 1 |
| #75 | tiny plastic Professor What | 1 |
| #3873 | tiny plastic Protagonist | 1 |
| #3908 | tiny plastic Spam Witch | 1 |
| #2194 | tiny plastic anime smiley | 3 |
| #3979 | tiny plastic apathetic lizardman | 1 |
| #8131 | tiny plastic barrrnacle | 1 |
| #4482 | tiny plastic bitchin' meatcar | 1 |
| #3927 | tiny plastic blooper | 1 |
| #3914 | tiny plastic cubist bull | 1 |
| #53 | tiny plastic dolphin "orphan" | 1 |
| #2802 | tiny plastic drunk goat | 2 |
| #3846 | tiny plastic fiendish can of asparagus | 1 |
| #3927 | tiny plastic fruit golem | 1 |
| #8193 | tiny plastic ghost pickle on a stick | 1 |
| #3905 | tiny plastic giant pair of tweezers | 1 |
| #327 | tiny plastic golden gundam | 1 |
| #8131 | tiny plastic howling balloon monkey | 1 |
| #8105 | tiny plastic levitating potato | 1 |
| #57 | tiny plastic orphan | 1 |
| #59 | tiny plastic reindeer | 1 |
| #46 | tiny plastic sea elf | 1 |
| #3953 | tiny plastic smarmy pirate | 1 |
| #2828 | tiny plastic spooky vampire | 2 |
| #2767 | tiny plastic taco cat | 2 |
| #3863 | tiny plastic topiary golem | 1 |
| #55 | tiny plastic wild beaver | 1 |
| #52 | tiny plastic yuleviathan | 1 |
| #175 | torn hellseal sinew | 39 |
| #447 | turtle totem | 86 |
| #972 | untamable turtle | 2 |