| 🥇 | Franken Stein | 1 |
| 🥈 | Abuela Crimbo's special magnet | 1 |
| 🥈 | All-Hallow's Steve's fright wig | 1 |
| #4297 | Baron von Ratsworth's monocle | 1 |
| 🥈 | Big Candy's tophat | 1 |
| 🥇 | Book of Old-Timey Carols | 1 |
| #1393 | CRIMBCO mug | 4 |
| #189 | CSA fire-starting kit | 85 |
| #571 | Chroner | 1 |
| #214 | Cloak of Dire Shadows | 1 |
| 🥈 | Crimbo smile | 1 |
| #18 | Crimbo training manual | 1 |
| #24 | Drip harness | 1 |
| #2028 | Drowsy Sword | 3 |
| #808 | El Sombrero De Lopez | 3 |
| #958 | FDKOL commendation | 2 |
| 🥈 | Fuzzby | 1 |
| #196 | Helm of the Scream Emperor | 1 |
| 🥇 | Jackass Plumber home game | 1 |
| 🥈 | Krampus Horn | 1 |
| #551 | La Hebilla del Cinturón de Lopez | 2 |
| #527 | Lederhosen of the Night | 2 |
| #3015 | Lord Spookyraven's ear trumpet | 3 |
| #525 | Order of the Silver Wossname | 1 |
| #232 | Purple Horseshoe of Honor | 1 |
| 🥇 | SalesCo sample kit | 1 |
| #125 | Science Notebook | 1 |
| #194 | Shield of Icy Fate | 1 |
| #176 | Shore Inc. Ship Trip Scrip | 2 |
| #538 | The Mariachi's guitar case | 3 |
| 🥇 | Thinknerd T-Shirt | 1 |
| #6 | Third Eye | 1 |
| 🥇 | Tickle-Me Emilio | 1 |
| 🥈 | Uncle Crimbo's hat | 1 |
| 🥇 | all-year sucker | 1 |
| #5 | anniversary gift box | 11 |
| #302 | bacon bath ball | 3 |
| #332 | batskin belt | 1 |
| #637 | bunny liver | 4 |
| #502 | chocolate bath ball | 1 |
| #252 | comfy pillow | 1 |
| #113 | crotchety pants | 1 |
| #223 | crusty hula hoop | 1 |
| #411 | donated booze | 8 |
| #210 | donated candy | 44 |
| #324 | donated food | 18 |
| #1926 | duct tape | 3 |
| #129 | duct tape dockers | 1 |
| #93 | duct tape fedora | 1 |
| #232 | duct tape sword | 1 |
| #5139 | easter egg balloon | 1 |
| #77 | eternal car battery | 2 |
| #1946 | facsimile dictionary | 1 |
| #1713 | filthy lucre | 4 |
| #108 | fried air | 3 |
| #493 | fuzzy montera | 2 |
| #587 | ghost of a necklace | 1 |
| #240 | giant marshmallow | 1 |
| #792 | gold wedding ring | 1 |
| 🥇 | hand-knitted Crimbo socks | 1 |
| #4484 | handful of confetti | 2 |
| 🥇 | heart of dark chocolate | 1 |
| #1397 | heart of the volcano | 2 |
| #236 | incense bath ball | 4 |
| #41 | jingle bell | 1 |
| #492 | left half of a heart necklace | 1 |
| #2848 | obsidian dagger | 2 |
| #74 | odd silver coin | 6 |
| #39 | old sweatpants | 1,228 |
| #334 | ornate picture frame | 2 |
| #103 | paperclip cape | 1 |
| #99 | paperclip pants | 1 |
| #91 | paperclip turban | 1 |
| #101 | paperclip-on tie | 1 |
| #562 | personalized coffee mug | 70 |
| #1613 | pork elf goodies sack | 1 |
| 🥇 | refurbished air fryer | 1 |
| #554 | right half of a heart necklace | 1 |
| #1034 | sawblade shield | 1 |
| 🥇 | silver cow creamer | 1 |
| #416 | skull of the Bonerdagon | 1 |
| #2992 | spectre scepter | 3 |
| #301 | sponge cake | 1 |
| #1003 | stray chihuahua | 2 |
| #8864 | stuffed angry cow | 1 |
| #269 | sucker bucket | 1 |
| #603 | tenderizing hammer | 1 |
| 🥇 | train whistle | 1 |
| 🥇 | wand of fudge control | 1 |