Schrieklich

RankItemQuantity
#228Das Überkühlraum trading card1
#2384Elder Turtle Shell1
#127Kevlar balloon1
#437Mace of the Tortoise1
#182Mylar balloon1
#228Vaso De Agua trading card1
#228Woldo trading card1
#129all-purpose flower1
#679anniversary balloon1
#122asbestos helmet turtle1
#93birthday party jellybean cheesecake1
#125blue velvet cake1
#141bottlecap turtle1
#230box turtle1
#94bubblewrap bottlecap turtleban1
#80cardboard box turtle1
#13chintzy turtle brooch384
#254chrome helmet turtle1
#57deadly nightshade1
#618deck of tropical cards1
#64furry green earmuffs1
#82gilded lily1
#882green balloon1
#3382heart necklace1
#1454heart-shaped balloon1
#1877helmet turtle1
#232knobby helmet turtle1
#68knobby kneepads1
#114linoleum helmet turtle1
#95meaty helmet turtle1
#69mini-zeppelin1
#364moonglasses1
#690mugcake1
#1060personalized birthday cake1
#489potted fern1
#90rat head balloon1
#73reinforced furry underpants1
#3637rubber WWBD? bracelet1
#3663rubber WWJD? bracelet1
#3658rubber WWSPD? bracelet1
#3648rubber WWtNSD? bracelet1
#68sebaceous shield1
#179sewer turtle1
#201skeletortoise1
#3320spade necklace1
#81stone turtle1
#8937stuffed Cheshire bitten1
#8942stuffed MagiMechTech MicroMechaMech1
#3170stuffed alien blob1
#8861stuffed angry cow1
#8973stuffed astral badger1
#8948stuffed baby gravy fairy1
#1466stuffed can of asparagus1
#8831stuffed cocoabo1
#1579stuffed dodecapede1
#3201stuffed doppelshifter1
#8923stuffed flaming gravy fairy1
#8970stuffed frozen gravy fairy1
#955stuffed ghuol whelp1
#8977stuffed hand turkey1
#8911stuffed mind flayer1
#8940stuffed scary death orb1
#8961stuffed sleazy gravy fairy1
#8803stuffed snowy owl1
#6997stuffed spooky gravy fairy3
#8878stuffed stinky gravy fairy1
#8891stuffed undead elbow macaroni1
#553stuffed yo-yo1
#509three-tiered wedding cake1
#767tortoise's blessing1
#1791turtle totem1
#586wang1
#903white balloon1

Wow, that's 458 items total!

what items are this player missing?