| #931 | Better Than Cuddling Cake | 1 |
| #421 | Boris's key lime pie | 1 |
| #751 | Crimbo pie | 1 |
| #1940 | Dolphin King's crown | 1 |
| #1494 | Dr. Hobo's scalpel | 1 |
| #594 | Gnollish pie server | 1 |
| #673 | Gnollish pie tin | 1 |
| #393 | Jarlsberg's key lime pie | 1 |
| #127 | Ol' Scratch's infernal pitchfork | 1 |
| #1594 | Pan-Dimensional Gargle Blaster | 2 |
| #397 | Sneaky Pete's key lime pie | 1 |
| #227 | anniversary chutney sculpture | 1 |
| #338 | banana cream pie | 1 |
| #771 | bouquet of circular saw blades | 1 |
| #272 | cherry pie | 1 |
| #938 | chocolate-covered diamond-studded roses | 1 |
| #432 | cream pie | 1 |
| #1025 | daisy | 1 |
| #369 | digital key lime pie | 1 |
| #256 | duct tape wallet | 1 |
| #1472 | enchanted leopard-print barbell | 2 |
| #1610 | flashing novelty button | 1 |
| #274 | flower petal pie | 1 |
| #948 | goat cheese pizza | 1 |
| #882 | green balloon | 1 |
| #981 | guy made of bee pollen | 1 |
| #1453 | heart-shaped balloon | 1 |
| #362 | lemon meringue pie | 1 |
| #623 | lihc eye pie | 1 |
| #689 | mugcake | 1 |
| #378 | mushroom pizza | 1 |
| #878 | oversized pizza cutter | 1 |
| #687 | pat-a-cake pendant | 1 |
| #224 | peach pie | 1 |
| #322 | pie crust | 1 |
| #430 | plain pizza | 1 |
| #811 | potted cactus | 1 |
| #332 | purple pixel pie | 1 |
| #1135 | ring of half-assed regeneration | 1 |
| #3657 | rubber WWJD? bracelet | 1 |
| #1701 | sandwich of the gods | 2 |
| #407 | sausage pizza | 1 |
| #889 | silver shrimp fork | 1 |
| #106 | spandex anniversary shorts | 1 |
| #337 | star key lime pie | 1 |
| #320 | strawberry pie | 1 |
| #6927 | stuffed MagiMechTech MicroMechaMech | 3 |
| #7759 | stuffed angry cow | 2 |
| #7002 | stuffed astral badger | 3 |
| #1465 | stuffed can of asparagus | 1 |
| #7680 | stuffed cocoabo | 2 |
| #1574 | stuffed dodecapede | 1 |
| #7011 | stuffed flaming gravy fairy | 3 |
| #8958 | stuffed frozen gravy fairy | 1 |
| #8902 | stuffed mind flayer | 1 |
| #1710 | stuffed ninja snowman | 1 |
| #8935 | stuffed scary death orb | 1 |
| #8951 | stuffed sleazy gravy fairy | 1 |
| #8794 | stuffed snowy owl | 1 |
| #7787 | stuffed spooky gravy fairy | 2 |
| #8868 | stuffed stinky gravy fairy | 1 |
| #7813 | stuffed undead elbow macaroni | 2 |
| #553 | stuffed yo-yo | 1 |
| #776 | stuffed zmobie | 1 |
| 🥇 | time sleigh | 1 |
| #727 | urinal cake | 1 |
| #902 | white balloon | 1 |
| #202 | yellow glowstick | 7 |