BBQ Magus

RankItemQuantity
#418Angry Farmer candy232
#680Happy Birthday, Claude! cake1
#679anniversary balloon1
#415awful poetry journal261
#1823cheap plastic bottle opener1
#464disturbing fanfic250
#86ice-cold fotie1,000
#908ketchup hound1
#495petrified time1
#422severed rocking horse head1
#1466stuffed can of asparagus1
#1579stuffed dodecapede1
#380thin black candle514

Wow, that's 2,265 items total!

what items are this player missing?