| Rank | Item | Quantity |
|---|---|---|
| #582 | Angry Farmer candy | 112 |
| #419 | Mick's IcyVapoHotness Rub | 99 |
| #598 | awful poetry journal | 111 |
| #554 | chaos butterfly | 200 |
| #690 | disturbing fanfic | 93 |
| #468 | furry fur | 124 |
| #402 | giant needle | 95 |
| #416 | heavy D | 133 |
| #301 | meat paste | 205 |
| #421 | original G | 124 |
| #434 | plot hole | 201 |
| #509 | thin black candle | 221 |
| #337 | tomato | 123 |